
When criminal law and company policy collide, the outcome often surprises people: an employee can be cleared for self-defense by police and still lose his job for the same incident. That’s the crux of the Stow, Ohio Circle K case—and it’s a pattern baked into U.S. employment and firearms law.
The Short Version
- Police described a violent attempted ATM theft: suspects used stolen minivans to ram a Circle K and moved toward the entrance before fleeing when a clerk fired seven shots.
- Stow police said the clerk, Kendrick Watson, lawfully possessed his firearm and faced no criminal charges.
- Watson says Circle K removed him from the schedule and ended his employment because of its no-weapons policy, which he acknowledges exists.
- In Ohio and most states, being justified in self-defense does not prevent a private employer from enforcing a weapons ban at work; courts have repeatedly upheld that distinction.
What Happened In Stow: A Violent Theft Attempt, A Defensive Response
In the early hours of November 2, police say a crew arrived at a Circle K in Stow in two stolen minivans and rammed the storefront to dislodge an ATM. After breaching the entrance and damaging the machine, the suspects approached on foot—until the overnight clerk, Kendrick Watson, fired seven rounds, prompting a retreat and flight from the scene. Watson later told local reporters he fired to protect himself and a coworker, believing they were in imminent danger. Stow police publicly stated Watson lawfully possessed his firearm and would not face criminal charges; they returned his firearm following the investigation. Whether one sees Watson as a model of composure under duress or simply a man making a split-second calculation, the criminal system treated his conduct as legally justified.
Employment, however, is a separate system with different rules. Within days, Watson said he was taken off the schedule; a manager later told him not to return. He attributed the decision to Circle K’s zero-tolerance weapons policy—a rule he said he knew before the incident. The company did not issue a detailed public explanation beyond the policy rationale, and there is no indication in public reporting of any allegation of criminal wrongdoing by Watson. In other words, the company’s action turned on policy enforcement, not on whether his shots were legally justified.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=870ACKiYdQM
Criminal Clearance Versus Employment Rules: Why They Diverge
Two bodies of law intersect here. First, self-defense. Ohio criminal law permits a person to defend against force, and prosecutors or police can decline charges where the facts support that defense. Second, private employment. In at-will settings—still the default in most of the United States—employers can set lawful workplace rules and terminate employees who violate them, even when the violation arises from an emergency response. Ohio courts have been explicit on that point: the right to defend oneself from unlawful force does not preclude termination from employment for violating workplace policy. Federal appellate authority applying Ohio law takes the same view; in the well-known Plona v. UPS line, the Sixth Circuit affirmed an employer’s right to ban firearms on premises and to discharge an employee who brought a gun to work, rejecting a wrongful-discharge claim premised on a purported public policy right to carry at work.
That separation of domains—criminal justification versus private policy—drives many outcomes that outsiders find counterintuitive. It is legally coherent. It can still feel harsh.
How Employers Think About Guns At Work
Retailers and logistics companies have spent decades building policies designed to minimize the risk of gunfire in customer-facing spaces. The rationale is twofold. First, OSHA’s general duty clause requires employers to provide a workplace free from recognized serious hazards; organizations often interpret that mandate as supporting resolute restrictions on firearms in stores and warehouses, layered atop broader workplace violence prevention plans. Second, civil liability concerns nudge companies toward uniform, easily enforced lines—zero tolerance—with the aim of reducing ambiguous judgment calls during high-stress encounters and limiting bystander risk when bullets fly across a forecourt or sales floor.
Weapon bans are only part of the architecture. Many firms pair them with training that emphasizes de-escalation, retreat, and property non-intervention—“nothing in the till is worth a life.” The intent is not to second-guess a clerk’s fear in the moment; it is to standardize behavior prospectively to reduce the frequency and lethality of violent clashes. Courts have generally backed that managerial prerogative, particularly in states—Ohio among them—where no clear public policy compels employers to permit firearms on their private premises.
Where The Law Leaves Room For Disagreement
The national map is not monolithic. So-called parking-lot or “guns-in-cars” statutes protect employees’ ability to store lawfully possessed firearms in locked vehicles on employer property, and several states recognize public-policy exceptions to at-will employment in narrow self-defense scenarios. The Utah Supreme Court’s decision in Ray v. Wal-Mart, for instance, held an employer may not fire an at-will employee who, unable to safely retreat, acts in self-defense against an imminent threat of death or serious injury. Other courts have sided with employers disciplining workers for handling firearms in ways they deem unsafe or violative of policy, even absent criminal charges. The upshot: outcomes turn on state law, the exact policy language, and the facts on the ground.
Ohio’s appellate landscape sits firmly on the employer-authority side of that spectrum. The Sixth Circuit in Plona emphasized that Ohio does not recognize a broad public policy protecting possession of firearms on private employer premises, and state cases have reiterated that self-defense rights in criminal law do not immunize employees from workplace discipline. That framework explains why Watson could be legally justified and yet unemployed.
The Practical Dilemma For Frontline Workers And Managers
What should a clerk do at 3:30 a.m. as two stolen vans batter the storefront and masked men converge on the door? From the worker’s vantage point, the risks are immediate and personal; waiting to see if an intruder is “only” after the ATM is a luxury that may not exist. From the employer’s vantage, firearms escalation in a populated retail space raises unacceptable risks to customers, employees, and passersby—risks policies are written to prevent categorically. Both perspectives are rational. The law, as currently configured in Ohio and many other states, resolves the tie in favor of the employer’s prophylactic rule after the fact, even where police deem the shooting justified.
That leaves a communications and policy-design challenge that companies often underestimate. Workers who understand exactly how zero-tolerance policies apply in dynamic, violent scenarios are less likely to feel blindsided by post-incident discipline. Conversely, if a company intends to allow a narrow carve-out for defensive use while still banning routine carry, that exception must be drafted with surgical precision—and will still carry litigation and safety trade-offs. Most employers choose clarity and enforceability over nuance.
Brave Circle-K Worker Fired for Defending Himself, Co-Worker as Video Shows 4 Would-Be Robbers Ramming Store with SUV https://t.co/o3Zn5tN40x
— The Gateway Pundit (@gatewaypundit) November 16, 2026
What This Case Signals Going Forward
The Stow incident illustrates a durable baseline: in jurisdictions like Ohio, private employers can prohibit firearms and enforce those bans even when an employee’s use of a gun would satisfy criminal self-defense. Employees who carry anyway accept that risk. If the public wants a different balance—stronger protection for defensive gun use by workers facing unavoidable lethal threats—the venue is state legislation or state high courts, not police departments or HR hotlines. Those changes do occasionally happen, as the proliferation of parking-lot laws and decisions like Ray demonstrate, but they are narrow, state-specific, and contested.
Sources:
thegatewaypundit.com, news5cleveland.com, eg.headtopics.com, fox8.com, firearmslaw.duke.edu, law.justia.com, ogletree.com, caselaw.findlaw.com










